localnews.ie

Anthony McGrath refused Supreme Court appeal over photocopied drink-driving certificate

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court described the issue as straightforward statutory interpretation, and said proving a photocopy through a live witness did not meet the constitutional threshold.

Anthony McGrath has been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in a drink-driving prosecution. The determination was issued on 11 October 2019.

The issue arose in a case stated from the District Court. The original statement of the breath analysis, under section 13 of the Road Traffic Act 2010, had been mislaid, so a photocopy was tendered in evidence.

The garda who operated the apparatus also gave oral evidence. The question was whether the presumption of validity under section 20(1) of the 2010 Act applies to a photocopied statement.

The High Court (Simons J.) answered yes. Its judgment was delivered on 12 April 2019, and Mr McGrath applied for leave on 12 June 2019, in time.

He said there are many thousands of such prosecutions and that the certificate will go missing in some of them. The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Charleton J. said it was not convinced.

It described the matter as straightforward statutory interpretation and said proving a photocopy through a live witness did not meet the constitutional threshold. Leave to appeal was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal