localnews.ie

Paul Barlow and shellfish firms refused Supreme Court leapfrog appeal against Minister

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said it would be better placed to judge whether a point of general public importance arises after any Court of Appeal hearing.

Paul Barlow and eight other plaintiffs have been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in long-running proceedings against the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources. The determination was issued on 11 October 2019.

The other plaintiffs are Woodstown Bay Shellfish Limited, Michael Crowley, Riverbank Mussels Limited, Gerard Kelly, Fresco Seafoods Limited, Tardrum Fisheries Limited, Alex McCarthy and Halcome Merchants (Ireland) Limited, trading as Alex McCarthy Shellfish. Ireland and the Attorney General are also defendants.

The High Court gave judgment on 22 March 2019, and its order is dated 31 May 2019. The applicants sought leave on 16 July 2019, in time, to bypass the Court of Appeal.

The applicants relied on the lengthy history of the litigation and on earlier Supreme Court involvement. These proceedings are referred to as "Barlow 1"; the related "Barlow 2" was decided in Barlow & ors v Minister for Agriculture & ors [2016] IESC 62.

The panel of Clarke C.J., O'Malley J. and Irvine J. saw a significant risk that an appeal would raise questions about the trial judge's findings of fact. It said the case might not "look much the same" as a direct appeal as it would after a Court of Appeal hearing.

It gave little weight to the history of the litigation. Leave to bring a leapfrog appeal was refused, and the court expressed no view on whether a point of general public importance may later arise.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal