The Supreme Court granted Peter Sweetman leave on 10 October 2019 to appeal directly from the High Court in his case against An Bord Pleanála, Ireland and the Attorney General.
The appeal will test whether the public has a right to be heard at the first stage of the substitute consent process for an unauthorised quarry, or only later. Sharon Browne is the notice party.
The quarry is at Ballysax, Co. Kildare, and is owned and operated by Ms Browne. It has no planning permission and no environmental impact assessment. Mr Sweetman and An Taisce sought to make submissions on her application for leave to seek substitute consent, but An Bord Pleanála returned them.
In the High Court, Eager J. refused relief, saying the legislative intention was clear and no right to make submissions at the leave stage should be implied. He refused leave to appeal on 14 January 2019.
Mr Sweetman argued that this left him no other remedy and amounted to exceptional circumstances. The respondents said the case did not meet the threshold for an appeal.
The panel of O'Donnell J., Dunne J. and Charleton J. said it would be in the public interest to clarify the scope of the public right to participate. It noted similar judicial review applications are coming before the courts on the same issue.
His application was filed late on 7 March 2019 because amended practice directions were not appreciated. The court extended time, noting Ms Browne's objections and her intention not to take part in the appeal.
The court said it will deal with Mr Sweetman's case together with An Taisce's connected case at case management.