The Supreme Court granted An Taisce leave on 10 October 2019 to appeal directly from the High Court in its case against An Bord Pleanála, Ireland and the Attorney General. Sharon Browne is the notice party.
An Bord Pleanála had returned submissions from An Taisce and Peter Sweetman on a quarry owner's application for leave to seek substitute consent. The Board's reading of the legislation was that it has no facility to receive public submissions at that stage.
The quarry is at Ballysax, Co. Kildare, and is owned and operated by Ms Browne. It is an unauthorised development with no planning permission and no environmental impact assessment. Kildare County Council had begun enforcement proceedings in the Circuit Court.
An Taisce sought an order quashing the Board's decision and declarations that it breached the EU Environmental Impact Assessment Directive and the Aarhus Convention. Eager J. refused relief in the High Court, saying no right to make submissions at the leave stage should be implied.
He refused leave to appeal on 14 January 2019. An Taisce argued that this left no other remedy and amounted to exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal. The respondents said the case did not meet the threshold.
The Supreme Court panel of O'Donnell J., Dunne J. and Charleton J. said it would be in the public interest to "obtain clarity on the scope, extent and meaning of the public right to participate". The question is whether that includes being heard at the leave stage or only at the main application.
The application was filed on 7 March 2019, late, because amended practice directions were not appreciated. The court extended time. It noted Ms Browne's objections and her stated intention not to take part in the appeal.
The court said Sweetman v An Bord Pleanála is connected and the two cases should be dealt with together at case management.