The Supreme Court has granted Alyssa Reeves, who sues by her mother and next friend Amanda Reeves, and Amanda Reeves leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. The determination was issued on 9 October 2019.
The respondents are the Disabled Drivers Medical Board of Appeal, the Minister for Finance, Ireland and the Attorney General. They opposed the grant of leave.
The case concerns the Disabled Drivers and Disabled Passengers (Tax Concessions) Regulations 1994 (S.I. 353/1994). The regulations are made under section 92 of the Finance Act 1989, which lets the Minister for Finance provide for certain tax repayments.
The application is particularly concerned with the medical criteria in Regulation 3. The first named applicant is agreed to be "severely and permanently disabled" within the meaning of section 92. The Board determined that the criteria in Regulation 3 had not been satisfied.
The applicants seek a declaration that Regulation 3 is ultra vires section 92. Their primary argument is that the power to make the regulations was unlawfully exercised by circumscribing or fettering the parent legislation. They also challenge the Board's decision for an alleged failure to give reasons.
The Court of Appeal had upheld the High Court's refusal to grant relief by way of judicial review. Its order is dated 28 March 2019. A related application, Lennon (A Minor) v Disabled Drivers Medical Board of Appeal [2019] IESCDET 213, raises the same regulations.
The panel of Clarke C.J., O'Malley J. and Irvine J. found that the constitutional criteria for leave to appeal had been met.
The application was filed on 17 July 2019, outside the time allowed under Order 58 of the Rules of the Superior Courts. The court said this was apparently because the applicants' legal advisers were unaware of an amendment to that order. It extended time up to 17 July 2019.