The Supreme Court granted Andrew Mangan leave to appeal on 4 October 2019 against a Court of Appeal decision that struck out his claims against Dr Brian Denham and Mount Carmel Hospital in Dublin. He sued through his mother and next friend, Lorraine Mangan.
Mr Mangan has cerebral palsy and will need lifelong care. He was delivered by caesarean section at thirty weeks' gestation on 11 January 1995 at Mount Carmel Hospital by consultant obstetrician Julian Dockeray, with Dr Denham responsible for his neonatal care.
He sued Mr Dockeray in a personal injury summons dated 17 June 2008. In November 2016 Mr Dockeray applied to add Dr Denham and the hospital as third parties, relying on an affidavit from his solicitor that raised the care Mr Mangan received after birth.
Mr Mangan then joined them as co-defendants, but the High Court (Binchy J.) struck out the claims against them on 2 May 2018. The judge found the pleadings disclosed no case in negligence and that the claims were bound to fail because Mr Mangan had no evidence to support them.
The Court of Appeal (McGovern J.) upheld that decision on 22 February 2019. It refused an adjournment so that Mr Mangan could try to obtain an expert report.
The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. found issues of general public importance. These include whether a pleading should be struck out where a plaintiff joins a new defendant on the basis that an existing defendant will blame that party, and the court's inherent power to strike out such a claim.
The court said that if the Court of Appeal's order stands and Mr Dockeray's argument on causation succeeds, Mr Mangan could lose his claim against whoever is found responsible. The final issues will be settled at the first case management hearing.
Dr Denham was also permitted to cross-appeal the Court of Appeal's ruling on the costs of his applications.