The Supreme Court has refused Denis Cremins and Sheila Cremins leave to appeal in their case with Knockacummer Wind Farm Limited. The determination was delivered on 14 February 2019.
The Cremins were the defendants. They asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal from the Court of Appeal. The wind farm company is the plaintiff and opposed the application.
The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 30 July 2018. The only real issue in the High Court and the Court of Appeal was how to read a contract. It turned on timing.
The Supreme Court said the contract was ambiguous. The judges in the lower courts had used different tools to resolve that ambiguity and reached different views.
The court said the law on interpreting contracts is well settled. It said this case was an example of applying that law to unusual facts. It said the Supreme Court is no longer normally concerned with correcting errors.
It found that the constitutional threshold had not been met. Leave to appeal was refused.