localnews.ie

Edward McCarthy refused Supreme Court appeal in Criminal Assets Bureau property order case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court also noted that his application for leave to appeal was filed outside the time limits set by the Practice Directions.

Edward McCarthy has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a Court of Appeal decision upholding a Proceeds of Crime Acts order obtained by the Criminal Assets Bureau. The determination was issued on 10 September 2019.

The order, made under section 3 of the Proceeds of Crime Acts 1996-2005, covers two properties. It prohibits disposing of or reducing their value, on the ground that the court was satisfied they constitute the proceeds of crime.

Mr McCarthy and his co-respondent Anthony Mullane appealed the High Court order of 3 March 2017 (Fullam J.). The Court of Appeal (Peart J.) dismissed their appeal on 28 February 2019 after considering four main issues, including hearsay evidence, the test for shifting the onus of proof and the source of funds.

Mr McCarthy argued that the Court of Appeal misdirected itself on the legal test and failed to consider the property rights of his partner and young children. The Court of Appeal had said one property was not a family home at that time as it was not fit for habitation.

The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. found no issue of general public importance. It said the issues were specific to his case and had been dealt with in line with well-established case law. Leave was refused.

His application was filed outside the time limits, but the court said it need not consider an extension.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal