localnews.ie

John James Mungovan wins Supreme Court leave to appeal damages ruling

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court granted Mungovan leave to appeal and extended the time limit for his challenge to a High Court order striking out damages claims linked to Clare County Council’s wastewater treatment register.

John James Mungovan won Supreme Court leave to appeal a High Court decision striking out damages claims over Clare County Council’s wastewater treatment register, in a determination dated 6 September 2019.

The Court also extended the time for the appeal. It did not decide whether the High Court was right to strike out the claims; it granted permission for that appeal to proceed.

Mungovan had sought damages for financial loss, arguing that the Council’s register of independent suitably qualified agents and consultants for wastewater treatment was unlawful and that his exclusion from it harmed his property rights. He also claimed malicious falsehood. He applied several times to join the register, but was refused. The Council withdrew it in March 2013.

The High Court had dismissed the damages claim based on the public law challenge, finding that it depended on establishing that the register had been unlawfully maintained. That claim could not proceed after the Court of Appeal upheld an earlier ruling that it was time-barred. The High Court also dismissed the malicious falsehood claim, but Mungovan did not seek leave to appeal that part of the order.

The appeal concerned the High Court’s refusal to adjourn the Council’s motion to strike out the damages claims while Mungovan pursued appeals about the time limit. The Supreme Court found that he had an arguable ground to challenge that refusal. It said the delay in appealing the High Court order should be excused and that the Council had suffered no prejudice.

The Court said the proposed appeal depended on the outcome of Mungovan’s separate appeal concerning the public law claim. It considered it in the interests of justice, and exceptional circumstances, to allow the challenge so both matters could be resolved together if necessary.

The determination was made by Chief Justice Frank Clarke and Justices MacMenamin and Irvine.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal