Christian Morris has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his defamation claim against Aloysius Ryan. The determination was issued on 2 September 2019.
The effect is that the High Court and Court of Appeal decisions stand, and Mr Morris cannot have a trial on the merits of his claim. The Supreme Court said that was because he delayed too long in bringing it.
His proceedings were started more than one year, but less than two years, after the alleged cause of action arose. No leave of the court had been sought beforehand, and Mr Ryan pleaded that the claim was statute barred.
Mr Morris later applied for an extension of time. The High Court (Gilligan J.) and the Court of Appeal (Whelan J.) both refused to extend time on the merits. He applied for leave to appeal on 24 May 2019, after the Court of Appeal judgment of 22 March 2019.
He argued that the Statute of Limitations stopped him having a trial. The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. said the Attorney General had not been joined to the proceedings to raise any constitutional question about the statute. It said the Court of Appeal fully considered the statutory criteria.
The court said whether those criteria were met was entirely dependent on the facts and raised no issue of general public importance. Leave to appeal was refused.