Liam Rabbitt has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a possession case brought by Permanent TSB plc, formerly Irish Life and Permanent plc. The determination was issued on 2 September 2019.
The bank sought possession of a family home, alleging very substantial arrears on a loan and mortgage. The Circuit Court and then the High Court (Meenan J.) found in the bank's favour and made an order granting possession.
Mr Rabbitt applied for leave on 14 February 2019, in time, after the High Court judgment of 25 January 2019. He argued the High Court judge acted wrongly over certain documents and that unfair contract terms were involved.
The Supreme Court panel of Clarke C.J., Dunne J. and Irvine J. said the document issue was specific to the facts of the case. On unfair terms, it noted the High Court judge had examined the contract and found no unfairness.
The court said the Constitution does not guarantee a further appeal in any category of case, including family home possession cases. Leave to appeal was refused.
One question remains undecided. Whether an appeal lies to the Supreme Court from a High Court decision on a Circuit appeal is under consideration in another case, Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC v Cannon. The court said it did not need to decide that point here.