Dhanwantee Bundhooa has been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in her case against the Minister for Justice and Equality. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 2 August 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Irvine J.
The High Court gave judgment on 21 December 2018, and its order was made on 15 January 2019. Ms Bundhooa applied to the Supreme Court on 28 March 2019, which was out of time. The Minister opposed leave.
She said the High Court decision means a person without a current permission cannot apply to regularise their immigration status. She also said the law remained uncertain after the Supreme Court's decision in Luximon v Minister for Justice. She raised the scope of what the Minister must take into account when exercising executive discretion.
The Supreme Court found that she had not shown how the first issue arose in her own case. It said the circumstances differed greatly from Luximon, because she had been without permission to remain in the State since 2011. On the third point, it said she had not applied to the Minister for permission to reside, so the trial judge's comments were obiter.
The court held that the constitutional threshold was not met and refused leave. The question of an extension of time did not arise.