localnews.ie

Laurence Carthy refused Supreme Court appeal over assault causing harm conviction

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

He was convicted at Naas Circuit Court in 2017 and argued that voice identification evidence and the sparse evidence in the case made the conviction unsafe.

Laurence Carthy has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for assault causing harm. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 1 August 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Irvine J.

Carthy was convicted at Naas Circuit Court on 26 October 2017 under section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. He was sentenced to three years in prison with 18 months suspended. The victim, his ex-wife, identified him as her assailant by his voice. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 29 March 2019.

He told the Supreme Court he had maintained his innocence from the outset and has no previous convictions. He argued that gardaí had a greater duty to seek out and preserve evidence where it is sparse. He also asked whether voice recognition evidence should be admitted without guidelines. He wanted guidance on the test for withdrawing a case from the jury. He also asked for a priority hearing because he is in custody.

The Director of Public Prosecutions said the relevant principles are well established and had been applied correctly at trial.

The Supreme Court agreed. It said the trial involved applying established legal principles to the facts, which the Court of Appeal found the trial judge had done correctly. It said an assertion that a lower court erred is not enough, and refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal