Ruth Moram has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case against the Watch Tower and Tract Society of Ireland, Andrew Beeston, Peter Van Bentham and Martyn Bell. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 31 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Irvine J.
The High Court dismissed her proceedings, in an ex tempore judgment in March 2017. The Court of Appeal (Peart, McGovern and Costello JJ.) upheld that dismissal on 28 March 2019. The basis was that the issues were res judicata, because they had been decided in earlier proceedings brought by her.
The courts also found the case an abuse of process under the rule in Henderson v Henderson. Any claim now advanced could and should have been brought earlier. The Court of Appeal said new matters she raised related only to a worsening of a previous condition or further evidence on an existing claim.
The High Court also made an Isaac Wunder order against her, and the Court of Appeal upheld it. Ms Moram argued that the facts were complex and relied on an earlier Supreme Court decision, Lopes v Minister for Justice.
The Supreme Court said her case was dismissed because earlier cases barred it, not because she could not prove the facts. It said the Isaac Wunder order was made on well-established principles. The earlier claims had been found statute barred. It found no issue of general public importance or interests of justice, and refused leave.