localnews.ie

Kevin Duke refused Supreme Court appeal in Dunnes Stores workplace injury case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had overturned a High Court finding of negligence against Dunnes Stores over a fall on shrink wrap in a storeroom, where he suffered a foot fracture.

Kevin Duke has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his injury claim against Dunnes Stores. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 31 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Irvine J.

Mr Duke, an employee of Dunnes, tripped on shrink wrap on 20 October 2013 while stepping off a pallet to fetch boxes of pizza from a storeroom freezer. He fractured a bone in his right foot. Dunnes accepted that the accident happened as he described.

The High Court (Barr J.) found Dunnes liable in negligence in a judgment of 3 March 2017. It assessed damages at €45,000, reduced to €36,320 for 20% contributory negligence. The Court of Appeal (McGovern J.) allowed Dunnes's appeal on 25 March 2019. It held that Dunnes had a training regime and that the proximate cause was Mr Duke's failure to take reasonable care. That overturned the finding of liability.

Mr Duke argued that the Court of Appeal decided the case on a basis raised only in that court. He also said it effectively found him 100% contributory negligent, and should have ordered a retrial. Dunnes disputed each point.

The Supreme Court said he had argued only that established principles were wrongly applied. That is a corrective role, not a matter of general public importance. It found the interests of justice did not require an appeal. His application was late, but the court said the question of an extension did not arise.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal