localnews.ie

Information Commissioner granted direct Supreme Court appeal in UCC finance agreement case

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will be heard alongside the enet case and concerns an RTÉ request for a finance agreement between University College Cork and the European Investment Bank.

The Supreme Court has granted the Information Commissioner leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a case with University College Cork. The decision was delivered on 31 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and O'Malley J.

RTÉ asked for information in a finance agreement between the European Investment Bank and UCC. UCC said the information was commercially sensitive, and the bank agreed. Both later said they were willing to release redacted versions.

The Commissioner found that the information was not commercially sensitive. He also found that UCC had not discharged the burden in section 22(12)(b) of the Freedom of Information Act 2014.

The High Court (Simons J.) reversed the Commissioner on 3 April 2019. It held that he had erred in how he read the "competitive prejudice" test. It also held that he had failed to consider the public interest test, and had erred on section 22(12)(b). It followed the Court of Appeal in the enet case.

The Commissioner asked to skip the Court of Appeal. He said the enet appeal will not decide every issue here. He also complained that UCC changed its position once the case reached court.

UCC did not oppose leave. It agreed the two cases should be heard together.

The Supreme Court agreed the case raises issues of general public importance. It said the criteria for a direct appeal were met. It will be heard with the enet appeal, the issues matter to the Commissioner's daily work, and an appeal to the Court of Appeal was unlikely to narrow them. The issues may be refined in case management to avoid duplicated arguments.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal