The Information Commissioner has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a Freedom of Information dispute with the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 31 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and O'Malley J.
The case began with a request from Gavin Sheridan for records on contracts between the Minister and enet, formally E-Nasc Éireann Teoranta, for broadband services. The request was refused on grounds of confidentiality and commercial sensitivity. Mr Sheridan appealed to the Commissioner, who ruled against the Minister. The Commissioner found that enet's competitive position would be prejudiced, but not "totally undermined". He decided that the public interest favoured release.
The High Court agreed with the Commissioner. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision on 6 March 2019. It found that the Commissioner had erred in applying the statutory presumption that a refusal is unjustified, and had wrongly introduced a requirement of "total undermining". In a passage expressed as obiter, it largely upheld the Commissioner's finding that the confidentiality exemption did not apply to a confidentiality clause in a contract between the Minister and a service provider.
The Commissioner argued that the Court of Appeal's reading of section 22(12)(b) is unclear and could make the review process ineffective. Mr Sheridan supported the application. The Minister did not oppose leave on the presumption, but sought leave in a cross-application on the confidentiality exemption in section 35.
The Supreme Court agreed that the section 22(12)(b) issue is a matter of general public importance. It said the other issues may be of systemic importance to the operation of the legislation. Leave was granted on each point in the application and cross-application, subject to refinement in case management.
The court is also granting leave in University College Cork v The Information Commissioner. The two cases will be heard together.