localnews.ie

Joseph Creedon refused direct Supreme Court appeal in DePuy hip implant case

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court had dismissed his claim because he lacked prior Personal Injuries Assessment Board authorisation, and the Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal should hear any appeal first.

Joseph Creedon has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. His case is against DePuy International Limited. The decision was delivered on 30 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and Irvine J.

Mr Creedon received two metal-on-metal hip replacements, in May and June 2007. DePuy made the implants. It recalled them worldwide in August 2010. He sued in November 2010 for personal injuries.

DePuy objected that he had no prior authorisation from the Personal Injuries Assessment Board. The High Court (O'Hanlon J.) agreed. She dismissed his claim in a judgment of 20 December 2018.

Mr Creedon argued that his claim was excluded from that requirement. He said the law was uncertain and that eight other cases against DePuy were affected. He asked to skip the Court of Appeal. DePuy opposed.

The Supreme Court said he had not shown exceptional circumstances for a "leapfrog" appeal. It said the core issue was a straightforward question of statutory interpretation. The Court of Appeal can decide it freely.

The court said other affected cases do not alone justify skipping that court. Leave was refused. His application was out of time, but the court said that question did not arise.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal