localnews.ie

Donal Kinsella refused Supreme Court appeal over cut to €10m defamation award

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had upheld his win against Kenmare Resources plc and Charles Carvill on liability but reduced the general damages to €250,000.

Donal Kinsella has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over the reduction of his defamation award against Kenmare Resources plc and Charles Carvill. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 29 July 2019. The judges were Clarke C.J., MacMenamin J. and O'Malley J.

In 2010, a jury awarded Mr Kinsella a total of €10m for a press release issued by the defendants. That was €9m in general damages and €1m in aggravated damages. The defendants appealed. They were given a stay on condition that they paid him €500,000.

In February 2019, the Court of Appeal ruled in Mr Kinsella's favour on all issues of liability. However, it found the general damages award disproportionate, perverse and irrational, and set damages at €250,000. It found there was no basis for aggravated damages. Mr Kinsella was ordered to repay the balance of the €500,000. The defendants were awarded the costs of one day of the appeal.

Mr Kinsella said the award left him with less than the sum already paid out. He also challenged the court's comparison with personal injury awards, its ruling on aggravated damages and its costs decision.

The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal's judgment did not depart from its earlier decisions. It noted that Mr Kinsella's counsel had told the trial judge there was no doubt about his ability to repay. Leave to appeal was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal