Marion Kane has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case against solicitor Diane Hallahan. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 12 July 2019.
Ms Kane retained Ms Hallahan in January 2016 in a family law dispute about access to her grandchild. An application in Cork District Court became the source of dispute. Ms Kane was unhappy with the outcome and made a complaint of misconduct to the Law Society.
The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal decided on 2 February 2017 that no prima facie case of misconduct had been made out. The High Court (Kelly P.) dismissed her appeal on 18 May 2017. The Court of Appeal dismissed her further appeal on 8 February 2019.
Ms Kane argued that the case raised a matter of public importance. She described herself as legally blind and unrepresented, and said she was at a disadvantage against a qualified solicitor. Ms Hallahan opposed leave.
The Supreme Court said it understood the challenges facing visually impaired applicants. It noted that the Court of Appeal's detailed judgment showed her complaints had been heard and considered in full. It found the constitutional threshold for an appeal was not met.
Both sides filed out of time. The court said it did not need to comment on that, because leave was refused.