Michael Butler has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case brought against him by Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 11 July 2019.
The High Court (Twomey J.) gave the bank judgment against Mr Butler for €521,427.26 on 3 April 2016, with costs to be taxed in default of agreement. The Court of Appeal (Irvine J., with Edwards and Whelan JJ. concurring) dismissed his appeal on 20 February 2019. It also dismissed his application for discovery of certain categories of documents.
Mr Butler argued that he should be allowed to resist judgment, or obtain a stay, because he had a potential counterclaim against the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland over lost title deeds. He appeared to argue that the corporate veil should be pierced. He also said he had not received a full or fair hearing in the High Court.
The Court of Appeal had a full transcript of the High Court hearing and found no error in its approach. It applied established case law on entering judgment in a liquidated claim where a counterclaim is alleged.
The Supreme Court said the case raised no issue of general public importance. It described it as an application of well-established law on judgment and discovery, which the Court of Appeal had carefully reviewed. Leave to appeal was refused.