localnews.ie

Gerard Hayes refused Supreme Court appeal over murder conviction

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

His appeal against the 2003 conviction for the murder of John Robinson was heard on a partly reconstructed transcript because the original record had been destroyed.

Gerard Hayes has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for murder. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 5 July 2019.

Hayes was convicted at the Central Criminal Court on 18 March 2003 of murdering John Robinson. Mr Robinson was stabbed in the early hours of 23 January 2000 in the house of Hayes's mother. The Court of Appeal upheld the conviction on 26 June 2018.

Hayes wanted to argue that the courts need clear guidance on how to hear a criminal appeal when a trial transcript or recording is missing. The original transcript and audio had been destroyed because he did not appeal for many years. The Court of Appeal worked from a partial transcript reconstructed from the trial judge's notes and other notes.

He also challenged the trial judge's direction to the jury. The Supreme Court said the judge was correct to tell the jury there could be no acquittal. Self-defence had been disavowed at the trial on his own instructions. Provocation was the only defence argued, and the jury rejected it.

The Supreme Court found no persuasive argument that the trial was unfair. It said there was no point of law of general public importance and no injustice to address. Leave to appeal was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal