Anthony Buck has been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on a miscarriage of justice application, in a determination dated 2019. The appeal will address how the Criminal Procedure Act 1993 distinguishes new facts from newly discovered facts.
Buck was convicted of the murder of David Nugent and robbery after a trial in the Central Criminal Court. The determination records that the murder took place at Clonmel, County Tipperary, on the evening of 8 July and the morning of 9 July 1996. Buck received a life sentence for murder and a 12-year sentence for robbery. His appeal was dismissed in 2002.
Buck later made two applications under section 2 of the 1993 Act, which provides a route for a convicted person to apply to the Court of Appeal on the basis of new or newly discovered facts said to show a miscarriage of justice. The first application was dismissed in December 2015, and the Supreme Court refused leave to appeal that decision in January 2017.
The Court of Appeal dismissed Buck’s second application after granting a motion by the Director of Public Prosecutions. Buck then sought leave to appeal that decision. His application was lodged outside the time limit, but the Supreme Court accepted his explanation and extended the time for making it.
Buck argued that the Court of Appeal had not distinguished between “new facts” under section 2(3) and “newly discovered facts” under section 2(4). The Supreme Court said the terms appeared to have been used without distinction in the Court of Appeal judgment, despite the apparent statutory difference. It found that this raised a question of law of general public importance about the interpretation and application of the two provisions.
The Court granted leave on that legal question alone. It rejected leave on the separate issue concerning Buck’s legal representation. The determination grants permission to bring an appeal; it does not decide the appeal on its merits.