localnews.ie

Shyani Devi Omrawoo refused Supreme Court appeal over deportation order

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Mauritian national argued that her years of lawful residence made her a settled migrant entitled to a full assessment of her private life rights.

Shyani Devi Omrawoo has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case against the Minister for Justice and Equality. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 25 June 2019.

Ms Omrawoo is a national of Mauritius. She entered Ireland lawfully in 2007, and her permission was renewed each year until it expired in September 2012. A deportation order was made against her in May 2016.

She argued that her earlier lawful residence made her a "settled migrant". She said she was therefore entitled to a full assessment of her Article 8 rights, to private and family life, before any decision to deport her. The High Court granted her an order of certiorari, and the Minister appealed.

The Court of Appeal said the possibility that a student might become a settled migrant could not be ruled out. It also found that residence on a time-limited student permission was correctly described as "precarious". The same Court of Appeal judgment was at issue in the Rughoonauth case, where leave was also refused.

The Supreme Court did not accept her comparison with its earlier decision in Luximon and Balchand. It said her submissions were made entirely at the level of principle and pointed to no facts suggesting a fuller assessment would have made a difference.

Her application was out of time because of a rule change in January 2019. The Minister did not oppose an extension, but the court said it did not need to consider one.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal