localnews.ie

Kevin and Carmel O'Brien refused Supreme Court appeal in Galway Free Range Eggs case

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple and Hillsbrook Eggs Limited had argued that EU egg marketing rules should override a passing-off ruling against their "O'Briens of Galway Free Range Eggs" brand.

Kevin O'Brien, Carmel O'Brien and Hillsbrook Eggs Limited have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a passing-off case brought by Galway Free Range Eggs Limited. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 25 June 2019.

The plaintiff sells eggs under the name "Galway Free Range Eggs". It complained that the defendants were selling eggs as "O'Briens of Galway Free Range Eggs". The High Court (O'Connor J.) refused the relief sought. It found there was no evidence of damage to the plaintiff's sales, reputation or goodwill.

The Court of Appeal reversed that decision in a judgment of 22 January 2019. It held that the marketing regulations did not require the words in question to be part of a brand name. It ruled that the plaintiff did not have to show actual damage and was entitled to an injunction to protect its goodwill, because the defendants' acts amounted to passing off.

The defendants argued that the Court of Appeal gave primacy to national law when it should have disapplied it. They said EU law gives the words "free range eggs" a form of protected speech.

The Supreme Court noted that the applicants referred to no specific part of the regulations. It said they had not engaged with the Court of Appeal's finding that the regulation has nothing to do with brand names. It refused leave to appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal