The Supreme Court has granted Patrick Ryan leave to appeal in his case against the Governor of Mountjoy Prison. The determination was delivered on 28 January 2019.
Mr Ryan wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal decision delivered on 21 June 2018. The Court of Appeal (Edwards J, with Birmingham P and Mahon J concurring) had upheld a High Court decision of Noonan J. The High Court had dismissed an Article 40 inquiry into his detention.
The inquiry arose from events in the District Court on 21 February 2017. Mr Ryan was before that court over an instalment order on a debt. He was committed to prison for seven days for contempt of court under the Summary Jurisdiction (Ireland) Amendment Act 1871.
The affidavit that started the Article 40 inquiry was sworn by a solicitor who had not been in court. It was based on information from Mr Ryan's son, who was also absent. The Supreme Court said it appears the information came from associates of Mr Ryan who were there. It described the information as seriously inaccurate and misleading.
The High Court dismissed the inquiry on two grounds. It found the proceedings were an abuse of process. It also found the District Court hearing was fundamentally fair. It said it could not state a case on the 1871 Act, because the Attorney General had not been notified. The Court of Appeal upheld all of this.
Mr Ryan sought leave on two grounds only. The first is that an Article 40 inquiry cannot be dismissed as an abuse of process. The second is that the High Court was wrong to find the hearing was fair.
The Supreme Court said the fairness question depends on the facts of the case. On its own it would not justify leave, and the general law on contempt in the face of the court has already been considered. The abuse of process question is different. The court said it raises an issue of general public importance. That issue is whether an inquiry can be dismissed on that basis, or whether the court is limited to asking if the detention is lawful.
The court also said it was in the interests of justice that Mr Ryan be allowed to argue both grounds. Leave is granted on both, subject to any refinement at case management.