localnews.ie

Anthony Fitzpatrick Supreme Court bid adjourned in Star Elm Frames liquidator costs case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court put off its decision on leave to appeal until it rules in a separate appeal involving the same liquidator and personal costs orders.

The Supreme Court did not grant or refuse leave to appeal to Anthony J. Fitzpatrick on 28 January 2019. It adjourned his application instead.

Mr Fitzpatrick was the voluntary liquidator of Star Elm Frames Limited. He wanted to appeal part of a Court of Appeal order of 27 April 2018. That order dismissed his appeal against a High Court order. The High Court had made him personally liable for costs to Michael Gladney, who petitioned to wind up the company. The Court of Appeal panel was Peart J, Irvine J and Gilligan J. Mr Fitzpatrick also sought to appeal the costs order made against him personally on the appeal.

He argued that the issue is of general public importance: when a voluntary liquidator may be ordered to pay costs personally. Mr Gladney disputed this. He said any decision should wait for the court's judgment in In the Matter of Ballyrider Limited (In Voluntary Liquidation), Revenue Commissioners v. Fitzpatrick. That appeal has been heard and judgment is reserved.

The Supreme Court said the Ballyrider costs issues arise in a different factual context. Both cases, however, concern personal costs orders against Mr Fitzpatrick as a voluntary liquidator. A full decision on leave will therefore wait until judgment is delivered in that appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal