Pat Fitzpatrick and Michael J. Flannery have been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. They are challenging a High Court ruling in their case against the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Sea Fisheries Protection Authority. The Supreme Court announced its decision on 12 June 2019.
The High Court (Ní Raifeartaigh J.) gave judgment on 30 October 2018. She held that the Authority's "time spent" method for calculating catches was lawful. The Authority used it for the fishing area known as Functional Unit 16. The judge found it did not conflict with Council Regulation (EC) No. 1224/2009, the EU fisheries control regulation. She also found the Minister did not act outside his powers by relying on that information to issue Fisheries Management Notices. The notices set catch limits on whitefish fisheries.
The applicants say the Authority replaced the fishing logbook system with its own scheme in that area. They argue the new method breaches EU law and affects all fishers with a similar quota. They say a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union will be needed.
The respondents did not oppose leave. They said the Authority acted within the regulation and that no reference is necessary.
The Supreme Court allowed a "leapfrog" appeal, which skips the Court of Appeal. It said both sides agree the case raises issues of general public importance. It gave weight to the urgency of a final decision and the impact on other cases. It also noted that an appeal to the Court of Appeal was unlikely to narrow the issues.
A preliminary matter remains for case management. The Court must decide whether to hold an early hearing on a possible reference to the Court of Justice, or an early hearing of the whole appeal.