The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Breccia and Irish Agricultural Development Company in their dispute with borrower Joseph Sheehan over surcharge interest. It granted them leave on 6 June 2019. The two companies are the first and second named defendants in Mr Sheehan's case.
Mr Sheehan took out two facilities with Anglo Irish Bank, in March 2006 and November 2008. Anglo later became IBRC, and special liquidators were appointed to IBRC in February 2013. Mr Sheehan said he wished to redeem the loans, but his two bids to buy them were rejected and Breccia bought them instead.
In December 2014, Breccia demanded €16,144,572. Proceedings began on 22 December 2014. In May 2015, Mr Sheehan was given a redemption figure of €19,663,673. The main difference was surcharge interest of 4% from 31 December 2010, amounting to €2,822,957.
The High Court (Haughton J.) found the surcharge was an unlawful penalty. It held that its dominant purpose was to deter default, not to estimate loss. It also found Breccia would have been estopped from claiming the surcharge, because of earlier representations by IBRC and Breccia's own demand for about €16m. The Court of Appeal upheld both findings on 30 July 2018, in separate judgments from Finlay Geoghegan J. and Hogan J.
Breccia argues that Irish courts should follow the UK Supreme Court's approach in Cavendish Square v El Makdessi. That test asks whether a clause imposes a detriment out of all proportion to a legitimate interest. It also says the Court of Appeal erred on whether Mr Sheehan's reliance created an estoppel.
The Supreme Court said the challenge to the penalty finding is stateable, noting that both Haughton J. and Finlay Geoghegan J. suggested the earlier principles might be reconsidered. It found the issues could affect many other lenders and borrowers. It also granted leave on the estoppel point in the interests of justice, since Breccia would otherwise gain no benefit from winning on the penalty issue.