The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Diesel Spa in its long-running bid to register DIESEL as a trade mark in Ireland. It granted Diesel leave to appeal on 6 June 2019.
Diesel is an Italian clothing company. Its application, dated 11 January 1994, sought to register DIESEL and DIESEL (device) as trade marks in class 25. Montex Holdings Limited, an Irish company in the fashion industry that also used the Diesel name, opposed it.
The hearing before the Controller of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks took place in May 2012. The Controller refused the application in a decision delivered in September 2013, criticising Diesel for not giving more evidence of its sales in Ireland.
Diesel appealed to the High Court under section 57 of the Trade Marks Act 1963. It asked to introduce a substantial body of new evidence. Binchy J admitted most of it, applying a less rigorous test than the one in Murphy v Minister for Defence.
On 2 October 2018, the Court of Appeal reversed that decision. Justice Hogan's judgment held that the Murphy test applies. Diesel sought leave to appeal that order, and the Controller and Montex both opposed.
The Supreme Court said it is stateable that the Court of Appeal wrongly treated the High Court appeal as equivalent to an appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court before October 2014. It found the test for admitting new evidence in a trade mark appeal is a matter of general public importance. Leave covers grounds 1 to 4 of the proposed notice of appeal on that basis. It also covers the remaining grounds, in the interests of justice.