Matthew Kirby has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in his case against Friends First Life Assurance Company Limited. The Supreme Court gave its decision on 5 June 2019.
The case concerns an income protection contract that the insurer repudiated because of non-disclosure of certain medical information. On 10 December 2018, the High Court found in favour of the insurer on liability. The order followed on 17 December 2018.
Mr Kirby, the plaintiff, then applied to skip the Court of Appeal and go straight to the Supreme Court. He argued that the principles in the 1981 case Chariot Inns v Assicurazioni Generali, which the trial judge applied, are unduly harsh on people proposing for insurance and need rebalancing. He proposed a test based on reasonableness and honesty.
A notice of appeal had also been lodged in the Court of Appeal. Apart from the Chariot Inns issue, it challenges several key findings of the trial judge, including her assessment of evidence.
The Supreme Court said a direct appeal requires exceptional circumstances, including whether the case would look the same after an appeal to the Court of Appeal. It found this was not such a case, because Mr Kirby would arguably still need to show the trial judge erred on the evidence. Leave was refused, so no extension of time was needed.