The Supreme Court will hear a State appeal in Graham Dwyer's challenge to Ireland's data retention law. It decided on 28 May 2019 to grant leave to the defendants to appeal directly from the High Court.
The defendants are the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána, the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Ireland and the Attorney General. Dwyer is the plaintiff.
Dwyer has been tried for and convicted of the 2012 murder of Elaine O'Hara. Part of the evidence against him at trial was obtained by gardaí under the Communications (Retention of Data) Act 2011. That Act allows telecommunications metadata to be retained and accessed, and was passed to give effect to an EU directive, Directive 2006/24/EC. The Court of Justice of the European Union declared that directive invalid in April 2014.
Dwyer then issued these proceedings challenging the Act. On 6 December 2018, the High Court (Justice O'Connor) declared that section 6(1)(a) of the Act, insofar as it relates to telephony data retained on a general and indiscriminate basis, is inconsistent with EU law. Dwyer says the main purpose of his case is to raise issues about whether evidence in his criminal case was admissible.
The defendants asked to bypass the Court of Appeal. They said the case raises complex and novel questions of constitutional and EU law with significant implications for many others, and will almost inevitably have to be decided by the Supreme Court. Dwyer agreed and did not oppose leave.
The Supreme Court accepted that the case meets the constitutional criteria for leave to appeal. Leave was granted on the grounds set out in the defendants' notice of appeal.