Doreen McEvoy, the second named defendant in a civil case over an alleged sexual assault, has been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 23 May 2019.
The plaintiff, who is identified in the case title only as M W, claims that the first named defendant, a former hospital consultant, sexually assaulted him in his private clinic in 1975. Ms McEvoy is sued as the representative of the Congregation which owned the hospital at that time. The Health Service Executive is sued as the statutory successor to the North Eastern Health Board, which bought the hospital in 1997.
The plaintiff set the case down for trial by judge and jury. The second and third defendants asked the High Court to set that notice aside, but the trial judge declined to do so. Ms McEvoy argued that the judge had misread section 1(3)(b) of the Courts Act 1988 and had not distinguished earlier authorities on the facts of this case. The plaintiff opposed the application.
She had also lodged an appeal in the Court of Appeal, listed for hearing on 4 June 2019. The Supreme Court said it no longer has the function of correcting errors, and that the case should proceed in the Court of Appeal first, given the near hearing date. If any party then believes a point of law of general public importance has arisen, it can apply at that stage.