The Supreme Court has refused Seamus Murphy leave to appeal against his convictions for assaulting a police officer acting in the course of his duty and for obstructing traffic. The determination was delivered on 22 May 2019. The Court of Appeal had upheld both convictions on 20 June 2018.
Mr Murphy originally faced four charges. The jury acquitted him of assaulting a second officer and of dangerous driving involving a tractor with a mower attachment.
He raised two issues. The first was evidence from Sergeant James Murphy, who told the jury that the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission had found the gardaí did nothing wrong on the night. The second was the prosecution's closing speech, which referred to Mr Murphy's "track record".
The Supreme Court called the first argument misconceived. It said the sergeant's evidence was inadmissible hearsay and opinion, but it was not evidence of bad character. It also said that inadmissible evidence does not automatically entitle an accused to have a jury discharged.
The court accepted that prosecution counsel should not have used that evidence in his speech. It said the matter was for the trial judge's discretion and noted the acquittals. It found no point of general public importance and refused leave.