The Supreme Court has refused Martin Padden leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision that dismissed his proceedings against Ireland and the Attorney General. The determination was delivered on 21 May 2019. The State respondents said the case did not meet the constitutional threshold.
Mr Padden began his case on 6 February 2009. It concerns his complaint to the Gardaí in 1999 that he and his brothers were seriously assaulted outside a pub in County Mayo. He alleged that he was later assaulted, arrested and falsely imprisoned, and maliciously prosecuted. The last prosecution ended in an acquittal on 14 February 2003.
After the defence was filed in May 2012, no steps were taken until 9 June 2015. The High Court (Barrett J.) refused to dismiss the case for delay on 6 December 2016. The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Irvine J. and Gilligan J.) reversed that on 31 January 2018.
Mr Padden argued there was no evidence of prejudice to the State. The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied well-established case law to the facts. It said another court might have decided differently, but that did not make the decision an error of law. It found no issue of general public importance and refused leave.