localnews.ie

Damian and Irene Gibney refused Supreme Court appeal over Court of Appeal hearing arrangements in Ken Tyrell case

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said appeals against case management decisions are allowed only in exceptional circumstances, and the couple had put forward no grounds for treating theirs as one.

The Supreme Court has refused Damian Gibney and Irene Gibney leave to appeal a Court of Appeal direction about how their pending appeal would be heard. The determination was delivered on 22 May 2019. The proceedings were brought against them by Ken Tyrell.

The couple, who represent themselves, have an appeal waiting in the Court of Appeal, which was listed for 30 May 2019. They issued a motion in that court seeking a number of declaratory reliefs, and they wanted the motion heard before the appeal itself.

The President of the Court of Appeal directed that the motion and the appeal should be heard on the same day. The Gibneys applied to the Supreme Court, within the time allowed, for leave to appeal against that direction.

The Supreme Court noted that it has said in earlier determinations that an appeal against a case management decision will be permitted only in exceptional circumstances. It held that the couple had put forward no grounds for considering that such circumstances arose, and refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal