localnews.ie

John O'Doherty refused Supreme Court appeal in AIB Mortgage Bank case after appeal struck out for delay

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

His Court of Appeal appeal, filed on 20 July 2015, was listed about 15 times before it was struck out on 7 November 2018 when he was in hospital.

The Supreme Court has refused John O'Doherty leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision that struck out his appeal in a case brought by AIB Mortgage Bank. The determination was delivered on 20 May 2019. The bank opposed the application.

Mr O'Doherty filed his appeal in the Court of Appeal on 20 July 2015. The case was listed on approximately 15 occasions. A hearing date of 7 November 2018 was fixed on 27 July 2017, and a request to adjourn it was refused on 19 October 2018.

On the hearing date a third party told the court that Mr O'Doherty could not attend because he had been admitted to hospital. The Court of Appeal (Peart, McGovern and Costello JJ.) was given no reason for the admission and no indication of when he could proceed.

The court struck out the appeal. It said it needed to "protect the processes of the Court and the administration of justice".

Mr O'Doherty argued that it was unjust to proceed in his absence and that he had been denied access to the courts. The Supreme Court said striking out was a matter for the Court of Appeal's discretion. It found no point of general public importance and no need in the interests of justice for an appeal, and would not interfere.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal