The Supreme Court refused Christopher McCarthy leave to appeal on 29 June 2018. He is charged with unlawfully using machinery to cut turf on a designated European site.
The charge relates to Moanveanlagh Bog, Co. Kerry, on 20 May 2012. The offence is tried on indictment. It carries a fine of up to €500,000, up to three years in prison, or both.
Mr McCarthy wanted to challenge the law behind the charge. He argued that the 2011 regulations were not required by Ireland's EU membership. He said the Minister had acted beyond his powers in making them.
The High Court rejected that argument. It held that criminal penalties could fairly be seen as necessary to apply the Habitats Directive. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision on 20 March 2017.
The Supreme Court said the case raised no point of general public importance. It also found no reason, in the interests of justice, to hear the appeal. The authorities cited to it had not been put to the lower courts and did not advance his case.
The Court noted that a refusal of leave decides that application only.