localnews.ie

Samantha Ahearne granted Supreme Court appeal over dismissal of her car collision injury claim

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will examine whether the Court of Appeal should have sent the case back to the High Court for a rehearing instead of dismissing it.

Samantha Ahearne has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court after the Court of Appeal dismissed her personal injury claim against Bill Tuohey. The Supreme Court gave its determination on 29 June 2018.

Ms Ahearne claimed damages for injuries sustained when Mr Tuohey's vehicle collided with hers. The High Court, in a judgment by Abbott J., found that he had been driving negligently but that she was guilty of contributory negligence.

It apportioned liability one third to Mr Tuohey and two thirds to Ms Ahearne. Judgment was entered against him for €20,453, and the trial judge made a differential costs order of €2,000 because the award was below the High Court threshold. A judgment of €18,453 was entered, with costs on the Circuit Court scale.

Mr Tuohey appealed the finding of negligence, the damages and the costs. On 29 November 2017 the Court of Appeal (Peart J., Irvine J. and Hogan J.) allowed his appeal and dismissed the proceedings. According to Ms Ahearne, it saw no evidential basis for four of the High Court's six findings of fact and held that the other two could not support negligence.

Her complaint is that the Court of Appeal also identified evidence on which the High Court could have found negligence. She argues it should therefore have sent the case back for a new hearing rather than dismiss it. Mr Tuohey says the case raises no matter of general public importance.

The Supreme Court said there was considerable substance in his response on general public importance. It found, however, a narrow issue that should be determined in the interests of justice. That issue is the manner in which the Court of Appeal exercised its jurisdiction on whether to send the case back to the High Court, given the basis of Mr Tuohey's appeal. The precise issues will be settled at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal