The Supreme Court will hear Bon Secours' appeal in Oliver O'Sullivan's MRSA claim. It granted leave on 29 June 2018. The applicant is Bon Secours Health System Limited, trading as Bon Secours Hospital. It appeals a Court of Appeal ruling that his claim was not out of time.
Mr O'Sullivan had surgery at Bon Secours Hospital, Cork, on 20 September 2005. He became severely unwell and was readmitted on 30 September 2005. On 4 October 2005 a consultant microbiologist told him he had contracted MRSA. He issued a personal injury summons on 19 August 2008. He claims the hospital was negligent in allowing him to contract MRSA.
The High Court found the claim was not statute barred. Kearns P. said time began to run on 22 February 2007. That was when Mr O'Sullivan received a preliminary report from a Dr Cummins. The Court of Appeal ruled on 24 January 2018. Ryan P. and Edwards J. held that time ran only from 16 May 2008. That was when he received a report from a consultant, Mr John Scurr. Irvine J. dissented. The judge would have held the claim statute barred. By 16 July 2006, the judge said, he had broad knowledge of the relevant act or omission.
The hospital says the majority rewrote the section 2 test under the Statute of Limitations Act 1991. It relies on Gough v Neary and other authorities. Mr O'Sullivan says the Court of Appeal applied that test correctly.
The Supreme Court said the application raises questions of general public importance. They concern how section 2 of the 1991 Act should be interpreted and applied. The court listed several earlier decisions it will need to consider. They include Gough v Neary, Byrne v Hudson and Farrell v Ryan.