localnews.ie

Gary Simpson granted Supreme Court appeal over Mountjoy Prison treatment and damages

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear his case directly from the High Court because more than 1,600 similar claims have been intimated to the State.

Gary Simpson has been granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in his case against the Governor of Mountjoy Prison, the Minister for Justice and the Irish Prison Service. The court gave its determination on 27 June 2018 after an oral hearing on 20 June 2018.

The parties told the court that more than 1,600 cases making broadly similar claims have been intimated to the State defendants, with proceedings started in approximately 1,000. The High Court judge in charge of the list will not hear other cases until the appeal process in this case is finished.

The trial judge gave a written judgment on 13 September 2017 and an ex tempore judgment, meaning one given on the day, on 16 November 2017. He found a breach of Mr Simpson's right to privacy and personal dignity but decided it was inappropriate to award damages. The State defendants do not intend to cross-appeal that finding.

The State did not oppose leave. The Supreme Court still held an oral hearing, because it wanted to be sure it could deal with the issues without an intermediate appeal to the Court of Appeal. It said leapfrog leave is not normally appropriate where there is a real contest on the facts. At the hearing, counsel for Mr Simpson accepted the trial judge's findings of fact for the purposes of any appeal. That meant the appeal would turn on the legal consequences of those facts.

The court identified three broad issues. The first is the principle for deciding when a prisoner's treatment is inhuman and degrading, and which circumstances of detention can be taken into account. The second is how positive and negative factors should be weighed. The third is when a court may decline to award damages despite a breach of constitutional rights, including whether an actual psychological or psychiatric condition must be shown.

The court said an early decision on the principles would help the High Court. A notice of intention to proceed must be filed within seven days. The parties must file agreed issues and facts by 18 July.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal