The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by North East Pylon Pressure Campaign Limited and Maura Sheehy over the approval of the North-South Interconnector. It granted leave on 25 June 2018 to appeal directly from the High Court. The approval was granted by An Bord Pleanála under section 182B of the Planning and Development Act 2000. The application was made by EirGrid, which is the notice party. The Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment, Ireland and the Attorney General are also respondents.
The High Court dismissed the challenge in a judgment of 22 August 2017, with the order made on 30 January 2018. The Supreme Court said leave is granted only on some of the points the applicants raised. It said issues four, five and seven raise points of general public importance.
Those points are whether the Board was lawfully designated as the "competent authority" for the project under the EU regulation on projects of common interest. The court also will hear whether that role created a conflict with the Board's role in approving the development.
If the designation was invalid, the court will consider whether that has any legal consequences for the Board's decision. It will also consider whether an environmental impact assessment is required for alternatives the developer looked at. The High Court judge had held that the designation was valid. He said any defect would not affect the approval, and he rejected the argument of bias as misconceived.
The court said the applicants had not put forward a stateable case on four other points. These were whether EirGrid could apply without landowners' consent, whether an approval is an "appendage to title", the access routes, and Brexit. The court noted a request for a preliminary ruling to the Court of Justice of the European Union by Humphreys J. in Holohan v An Bord Pleanála. It concerns how alternatives are dealt with in an environmental impact assessment.
Because of the need for speed, the court shortened the time to serve a notice of intention to proceed to three days. The applicants' submissions are due by 11 July and the respondents' by 25 July. Case management is on 27 July.