Barry White has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over how a costs law applies when a claim succeeds against only one of two respondents. The court gave its determination on 6 June 2018.
Mr White had sued the Bar Council of Ireland and the State parties. His claim against the Bar Council concerned Rule 5.21 of its Code of Conduct, which is meant to stop a retired judge practising in a court of equal or lesser jurisdiction to the one he or she sat in. His claim against the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland and the Attorney General concerned the Minister's refusal to put his name on the panel of counsel eligible for payment under the criminal legal aid regulations.
The High Court found the Minister had acted ultra vires, arbitrarily and unreasonably, and in breach of his right to earn a livelihood. It found no need for any relief against the Bar Council. Costs were then awarded against Mr White in favour of the Bar Council, and against the Minister in favour of Mr White.
Mr White asked for what is called an "order over" under section 78 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936. That would make the Minister reimburse him for the costs he had to pay the Bar Council. Barrett J. made that order in a costs judgment on 31 March 2017.
The Minister appealed, and the Court of Appeal vacated the order in a judgment of 23 February 2018. It held that section 78 applies where two defendants may be liable in the same cause of action arising on the same facts. It said the claims here were completely different. Mr White says that interpretation appears to overturn the Supreme Court's decision in O'Keeffe v Russell. The respondent says it was the High Court that interpreted the section wrongly.
The Supreme Court said section 78 could apply in any case against two or more defendants or respondents where the claimant wins against only some of them. It found a point of law of some general importance and granted leave on the correct interpretation of the section and how it applies here. The court also reminded both parties of the risk of prosecuting and resisting a further appeal, since the costs order is the only issue raised.