The Supreme Court has refused Marta Herda leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's rejection of her murder conviction appeal. It gave its determination on 21 May 2018.
Ms Herda was convicted by a majority verdict on 28 July 2016, after a seventeen-day trial in the Central Criminal Court. The conviction was for the murder of Csaba Orsas on 26 March 2013 in Arklow, County Wicklow. She received the mandatory sentence of life imprisonment.
She raised seventeen grounds in her appeal to the Court of Appeal. That court, in a judgment of 12 October 2017 delivered by Mahon J. with Birmingham and Whelan JJ. agreeing, rejected each of them.
In her application to the Supreme Court she grouped her arguments into seven categories. They included how the trial judge directed the jury on recklessness, the standard of proof and the defence case, as well as confession warnings. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave.
The Supreme Court said six of the seven points were a re-run of arguments the Court of Appeal had dealt with. On the point about confession warnings, it found nothing giving cause for concern about the fairness of her trial.
The court also said it disregarded a letter it received from the Polish Ambassador. It refused leave under Article 34.5.3° of the Constitution.