localnews.ie

Minister for Finance refused Supreme Court appeal over High Court costs in Irish Life and Permanent case

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the Minister's application depended on the plaintiffs getting leave, which it had refused to all of them on the same day.

The Supreme Court has refused the Minister for Finance leave to appeal a High Court costs decision, in a determination delivered on 15 May 2018.

The case was brought by Gerard Dowling, Padraig McManus, Piotr Skoczylas and Scotchstone Capital Fund Limited. They challenged a direction order concerning Irish Life and Permanent. The High Court decision under challenge was delivered on 1 December 2017. It refused to award the Minister costs against the unsuccessful plaintiffs.

The High Court ordered that Mr Dowling and Mr McManus should recover 20% of their outlay. It ordered that Mr Skoczylas should recover 40% of his outlay. It also ordered that Scotchstone Capital Fund Limited should recover 30% of its legal costs, to be taxed if the sides did not agree.

The Minister applied in February 2018, which was out of time, and asked the court for an extension. He said the application responded to the plaintiffs' appeal, which was served on the last day for appealing.

The Minister did not say the issues raised a point of law of general public importance. He relied on the interests of justice, so a cross-appeal could be heard alongside any appeal by the plaintiffs.

His application depended on the plaintiffs getting leave for a direct appeal. The Supreme Court refused leave to all of them on the same day. That removed an essential ground for the Minister's application, the court said, and the application became redundant.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal