The Supreme Court has refused Piotr Skoczylas and Scotchstone Capital Fund Limited permission to appeal directly from the High Court. It gave its determination on 15 May 2018.
The two applicants had challenged a direction made on 26 July 2011 under section 9 of the Credit Institutions (Stabilisation) Act 2010 concerning Irish Life and Permanent Group Holdings Plc and Irish Life and Permanent Plc. O'Malley J. dismissed their challenge in the High Court on 31 July 2017. The Minister for Finance was the respondent, and Permanent TSB Group Holdings Plc and Permanent TSB Plc were notice parties.
The applicants wanted to skip the Court of Appeal and go straight to the Supreme Court. They pointed out that the proceedings began in 2011 and had run for six and a half years.
The Supreme Court said that a direct appeal needs exceptional circumstances, and it found none. It noted that the 2010 Act has lapsed and that the case no longer has importance for the financial sector as a whole. It also said an appeal would not settle the wider dispute between the parties.
Related appeals are already before the Court of Appeal, and the court said the same courts should deal with the connected issues. It described the application for leave as extraordinarily and unnecessarily lengthy.