Zanas Dzuigas has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a High Court order that he be surrendered to Lithuania. The Supreme Court gave its determination on 4 May 2018.
Lithuania sought his surrender under a European Arrest Warrant dated 20 December 2006, so that he could serve a sentence of one year and three months for two offences. That sentence had first been suspended on conditions, and the suspension was revoked on 2 May 2007.
Mr Dzuigas argued that one of the two offences, described in translation as "high handedness", has no matching offence in Ireland. Donnelly J. found in a judgment delivered on 2 February 2018 that its facts corresponded to theft here. She made the surrender order on 23 February 2018, and refused a certificate allowing an appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court said the High Court judge had applied well-established principles for deciding whether offences correspond. It found no question of general public importance in her decision, or in how she read the meaning of "dishonestly" in theft law.
It also did not accept that leave was in the interests of justice. The court said it is no longer an appellate court for the correction of errors, and that the refusal of a certificate does not on its own meet that test.