localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear West Wood Club appeal in Dún Laoghaire Rathdown rates and State aid case

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

West Wood argues that rates and State funding for council-run leisure centres amount to unlawful State aid; the council has asked for a priority hearing if leave is granted.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by West Wood Club Limited in a dispute with Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Council over unpaid rates. It granted leave to appeal on 30 April 2018. The council is the rating authority for its area. West Wood operates leisure and fitness clubs, including one at Leopardstown, County Dublin. The council has brought three sets of Circuit Court proceedings for unpaid rates for 2011, 2012 and 2013. It claims €176,800 for each of 2011 and 2012, and €173,264 for 2013.

West Wood's defence is that the council's receipt of rates and State grants, and its spending on leisure centres that compete with West Wood's, amounts to unlawful State aid. The council argued the Circuit Court could not hear that defence. The Circuit Court agreed.

On appeal, the High Court found the Circuit Court could decide whether the rates amount to State aid. It said the Circuit Court could not decide whether any such aid is compatible with the internal market. O'Malley J. delivered that judgment on 17 December 2015 and referred three questions to the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal answered on 25 July 2017. Hogan J. delivered the judgment, with Peart J. and Hanna J. agreeing. It said the Circuit Court can consider a State aid defence only where there is a clear error on the face of the proceedings, or no doubt about the illegality of the decision. It also said the Circuit Court cannot rule on the general validity of a rate.

West Wood applied for leave on 1 November 2017, which was out of time, and asked for an extension. The council did not oppose that. It intends to ask the Supreme Court to uphold the Court of Appeal's decision on other grounds. The Supreme Court said the parties' agreement was not enough on its own. It was satisfied, however, that the Court of Appeal's decision involves matters of general public importance. It said the issues are potentially wide in significance, including the supremacy of EU law, and that it is desirable for the court to provide clarity.

Leave was granted on the three questions referred by the High Court, subject to possible change during case management. The court also allowed West Wood to argue that it should have the costs of the High Court and Court of Appeal hearings.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal