The Supreme Court has refused Nisa Vaqar Un leave to appeal directly from the High Court in her case against the Refugee Appeals Tribunal. The determination was delivered on 26 April 2018.
She brought the case with her three minor children, who sued through her as their mother and next friend. The Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland and the Attorney General were also respondents.
The application was for what the court calls leapfrog leave, which lets a case skip the Court of Appeal. The High Court had ruled on 26 June 2017 and 24 October 2017, and its order was made on 14 November 2017.
The Supreme Court noted that the applicants had also appealed to the Court of Appeal. Nothing had been put to it suggesting that appeal could not go ahead. The respondent opposed leave.
The court said the notice of application was diffuse and lengthy. It considered that the Court of Appeal examining all the issues would bring greater clarity. It also said the parties disagreed over whether this was a true test case.
The Supreme Court expressed no view on whether the case raised issues of general public importance. It said it would consider the matter afresh if either side later asked for leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal.