The Supreme Court granted Sinead Fitzpatrick and Allan Daly leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their case against An Bord Pleanála, on 26 April 2018. Galway County Council and Apple Distribution International are notice parties.
The High Court gave judgment on 12 October 2017, and its order was made on 1 November 2017. Their application for leave was filed on 1 December 2017 and was technically out of time by the minimum amount, so the Court extended time.
The Court held a brief oral hearing on 9 February 2018, and the parties then filed further short written submissions. An Bord Pleanála opposed leave.
The central issue is how the Board was required, in law, to have regard to the possible expansion of the project through the construction of further data halls, up to and including eight. The Board said the High Court had only applied well established principles of European law to the facts.
The Supreme Court was not persuaded that it could safely say no point of general importance arises. It said it was not indicating that such a point necessarily arises, and that it must also consider whether it is obliged to make a reference to the Court of Justice under the CILFIT case law.
The Court noted that the Board says some of the grounds are new. It directed that a notice of intention to proceed be filed within seven days of the determination, failing which the leave will lapse.
An early case management hearing will follow, before written submissions. It will cover the scope of the grounds, whether to hold an early preliminary hearing on a Court of Justice reference, and expedited directions.